Short sale Archives - Page 2 of 3 - Real Estate News and Commentary

May 2, 2012September 29, 2019

Non-hardship short sales on the rise

by Dan Krell ©2012
DanKrell.com

A March 2012 Housing Wire piece (housingwire.com) indicated that CoreLogic recently reported that there were 11.1 million home owners who owed more on their mortgages than what their home is worth, which roughly translates to 22.8% of all mortgages being underwater. At one time, most home sellers applying for a short sale were experiencing hardships and foreclosure. However, as the housing market continues to recover- an increasing number of short sale listings are from sellers who are current on their mortgage and are not experiencing hardships.

For home owners who are experiencing financial difficulty, there are a number of options available to keep your home; however often a last resort- the short sale is one alternative to losing your home to foreclosure. However, home owners who need to sell their homes (because of a job transfer, divorce, or other reason), but are not otherwise experiencing a financial difficulty nor hardship, are also turning to the short sale process because of depressed home sale prices.

Although short sale horror stories still circulate, much has changed and many lenders have attempted to “streamline” their short sale process. Still, this has not prevented Congress from attempting to force lenders to provide speedy short sale decisions. In 2010, H.R. 6133 H.R.: Prompt Decision for Qualification of Short Sale Act of 2010 was introduced to require a 45 day response from lenders, however it “died” in committee. A recent form of this legislation was introduced in 2011 (H.R. 1498: Prompt Decision for Qualification of Short Sale Act of 2011), but GovTrack (govtrack.us) gives the bill an 8% chance of becoming law. Another bill, S. 2120: Prompt Notification of Short Sales Act, was introduced in February; GovTrack gives that a 2% chance of being enacted.

Beware of the circulated “wisdom” regarding short sales, because it is not always reliable or accurate (e.g., hardships and delinquencies). If your home has negative equity (underwater) and you want to sell, consult with an attorney; there are financial and legal issues that may affect you presently and in the future. The short sale process may seem straightforward, but it can get complicated quickly (especially if there are multiple mortgages involved). Many experienced short sale agents work in tandem with attorneys to make the process much smoother than otherwise would be expected.

If you’re an underwater home seller, but have assets and are not experiencing a hardship, your attorney can advise you on the short sale process. The issue pertaining to a successful short sale is not always about the seller’s financial status; but rather, a short sale is more about the amount the lender will accept as payoff for the existing mortgage. Yes, the lender will collect your financial information to use in their short sale determination; but a skilled negotiator may be able to reduce the overall mortgage payoff (even if you have to bring funds to closing).

Finally, an attorney is the only person who can provide you legal advice. Real estate agents advising you to stop making payments on your mortgage or to “fudge” your short sale application could be putting you in a precarious position: your credit can be affected, or your home can go to foreclosure when payments are stopped; providing false or misleading information to your lender is fraud (lenders and law enforcement are working together to stop short sale fraud).

Additional information about short sales:
Short sale is an option
Don’t be pushed into a short sale
House bill proposes 45 day lender response on short sale
Mortgage fraud on the rise

More news and articles on “the Blog”
This article is not intended to provide nor should it be relied upon for legal and financial advice. This article was originally published in the Montgomery County Sentinel the week of April 30, 2012. Using this article without permission is a violation of copyright laws. Copyright © 2012 Dan Krell.

January 12, 2012November 11, 2012

Buying a home after a foreclosure or shortsale

by Dan Krell
© 2012
DanKrell.com

If you’ve been through tough financial times, you know that it feels as if your financial picture may never improve. But for most people, experiencing a financial challenge turns out to be just a blip in time; they eventually move on with their life. Given that notion, mortgage lenders know that people endure temporary financial problems through their lives- underwriting guidelines may allow for a past foreclosure, short-sale, or even bankruptcy.

In the old days (prior to desktop underwriting), underwriting was “manual,” meaning that a loan’s approval or denial was decided by a human who reviewed your file. If you were lucky enough to borrow from the local small neighborhood lender, there was a very good chance they knew you, your family, and your financial circumstances (much like the Bailey Building and Loan from “It’s a Wonderful Life”); you had a chance to provide explanations and compensating factors to increase your chance of being approved.

Today, mortgage underwriting is mostly accomplished through automated systems, such as “Desktop Underwriter” and “Loan Prospector.” The automated systems make decisions based on algorithms and do not have the ability to weigh circumstances for negative reports on a credit history. Some lenders may still provide manual underwriting, but borrower requirements have become increasingly strict (including higher minimum credit scores).

Take heart; you still may be able to get a mortgage after a foreclosure, short-sale, or bankruptcy.

For conventional mortgages underwritten with Fannie Mae guidelines, you’ll have to wait at least seven years after a foreclosure. Likewise, you’ll have to wait seven years after a short-sale- unless you can muster a large downpayment (you may be able to qualify: after two years with a 20% downpayment; and four years with a 10% downpayment)! You’ll have to wait four years after a chapter 7 bankruptcy is discharged; and two years after a chapter 13 is discharged (but four years if the chapter 13 is dismissed).

For FHA mortgages, you’ll have to wait at least three years after a foreclosure, two years after a chapter 7 bankruptcy discharge, and one year current on a chapter 13 payment plan (with court approval). A short-sale is differentiated depending if the loan was in default: if the loan was not in default at the time of the short-sale and your previous 12 months payments were timely, you may be eligible for a FHA mortgage; however if the loan was in default prior to short-sale, you will have to wait at least three years before you can qualify.

If you are eligible for VA financing, you will have to wait two years after a foreclosure, short-sale, and chapter 7 bankruptcy (one year into a chapter 13 payment plan with court approval). However, if your foreclosure or short-sale was on a VA mortgage, then your eligibility may be reduced.

If you’re financial issues were caused by circumstances beyond your control, you may be able to get an exception that could shorten the waiting periods. However, you’ll have to provide documentation for the underwriter to review, and not all lenders grant such exemptions.

There are many different mortgage programs, and underwriting guidelines vary. The timelines and requirements posted here are as of time of article; it’s very possible that these guidelines will or have changed. It’s important to talk to a licensed loan officer to know what you need to qualify, as well as which mortgage program will be best for your particular circumstances.

More news and articles on “the Blog”
This article is not intended to provide nor should it be relied upon for legal and financial advice. This article was originally published in the Montgomery County Sentinel the week of January 9, 2012. Using this article without permission is a violation of copyright laws. Copyright © 2012 Dan Krell.

September 22, 2010October 5, 2019

House Bill Proposes Prompt Short Sale Decisions: H.R. 6133 requires 45 day response

by Dan Krell © 2010

A recently published study by CoreLogic (“The Cost of Short Sales: CoreLogic Research Study”; August 2010) indicated the number of short sales tripled since 2008. The study also indicated that “short sales will continue to be a significant factor for the housing industry.” Additional telling data from CoreLogic’s second quarter Negative Equity Report (2010) indicates that 23% of all properties with a mortgage (approximately 11 million) are in a negative equity position (also referred to as under water or upside down).

For many, this news does not come as a surprise; which is why short sales have become the focus of a new bill introduced last week in the House of Representatives by Rep. Robert Andrews (D-NJ) and Rep. Thomas Rooney (R-FL). The “Prompt Decision for Qualification of Short Sale Act of 2010” was referred to the House Committee on Financial Services on September 15th and, although approximately five pages in length, could potentially impact the housing industry.

Representative Rooney stated, in a September 16th press release regarding the bill, that short sales in his state of Florida are rising, “but lenders haven’t always been able to keep pace”… “By requiring lenders to make decisions on short sales within 45 days, this legislation would speed transactions and help prevent homes from going into foreclosure.”…”This bill would spur growth in the housing market by helping sellers and buyers complete short sales quickly.”

Anyone familiar with a short sale knows that there is uncertainty as to the length of time the seller’s lender will respond to a short sale request; which prompts many buyers and real estate agents to shy away from them. Additionally, some buyers who take a chance on a short sale walk away because the transaction takes too long. These are just a few factors that contribute to failed short sales which add to the foreclosure roll.

The bill, also known as “H.R. 6133: To Require The Lender Or Servicer Of A Home Mortgage, Upon A Request By The Homeowner For A Short Sale, To Make A Prompt Decision Whether To Allow The Sale,” is intended to provide a timeline for the lender to provide a response to a short sale request. The basics of the bill states that the home seller’s lender has 45 days to provide an answer to a short sale request when the seller submits all lender required short sale information and a fully executed sales contract. The lender’s response could be an approval, a conditional approval, or a request for additional information. If the lender fails to respond to the request within 45 days, then the short sale request will be considered to have been approved.

Although the bill puts a necessary spotlight on one weakness of the housing market, the bill obviously falls short in a number of areas. Besides the limitations already specified within the bill, the bill fails to address the complexity of a short sale with multiple lenders as well as the possibility that lenders may “game the system” by issuing requests for additional information or provisional approvals by the 45th day then take several additional months to make a final decision.

Unfortunately, many bills do not make it out of Committee and the odds of passing this particular bill are slim. Ironically, we won’t know the outcome for several or more months.

This article is not intended to provide nor should it be relied upon for legal and financial advice. This article was originally published in the Montgomery County Sentinel the week of September 20, 2010. Using this article without permission is a violation of copyright laws. Copyright © 2010 Dan Krell.

March 17, 2010June 28, 2019

HAFA – a misunderstood program

As April 5th approaches, everyone is excited about the official start of the Home Affordable Foreclosure Alternatives (HAFA) program. HAFA is a major development to curb the number of foreclosures by allowing home owners the opportunity to sell their home through the short sale process. Many incorrectly misunderstand the program to approve all short sales; however, it is a measure to facilitate lenders’ loss mitigation processes (the process that lenders use to determine the manner in which to dispose of property and lose the least amount of money) that includes short sales, deed-in-lieu (of foreclosure), and foreclosure.

To provide assistance to financially challenged home owners, the Making Home Affordable program (MHA) was announced February 2009. The program was devised to assist eligible home owners retain their homes by either mortgage modification or refinance. HAFA was introduced in May of 2009 to provide structure to the seemingly convoluted loss mitigation process (www.treas.gov).

You probably already know that a short sale occurs when a home owner sells their home for less than what they owe their lender. In a short sale, the lender is asked to give their blessing and to “forgive” the difference between the sale price and what is owed. Home buyers often seek out short sales as a means of purchasing a “bargain” priced home. Unfortunately, the traditional short sale is typically a lengthy process that is full of pitfalls; but for patient home buyers the short sale is worth the wait.

On average, it is not unusual to wait 2 to 4 months to receive third party approval for a short sale; some short sale approvals can take much longer. Reasons for lengthy waits for short sale approvals are complex and varied, but may be due to (and not limited to) consultations with bond holders (of mortgage backed security within which the loan was pooled), a vast backlog of files, and the loss mitigation process itself.

The HAFA program is intended to reduce the cost and impact of foreclosure to lenders as well as neighborhoods. The program allows the home owner 90 days (or more depending on the market) to procure a buyer for their home at a sale price that is set by their lender; this allows a home buyer to purchase the short sale without waiting months for a short sale approval. If the short sale period ends unsuccessfully, the home owner must give the home back to the lender via a deed-in-lieu.

Foreclosure proceedings are allowed to coincide with the short sale, however the foreclosure sale is deferred until the short sale process is concluded. Monetary incentives are given to participating lenders as well as to home owners who adhere to the program until its fruition. Eligible home owners will be accepted into the HAFA program until December 31, 2012.

Since HAFA will officially begin in a few weeks, information is being provided through many outlets. It is understandable that some of the information provided is incorrect and/or sensationalized. To qualify for HAFA, the home owner must be eligible for MHA (mostly, loans that have been bought by Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac) but either did not qualify for a modification or was unable to complete the process. If you are unsure of your eligibility, program guidelines, and additional information, check with your lender and/or the Making Home Affordable website (www.makinghomeaffordable.gov).

This article is not intended to provide nor should it be relied upon for legal and financial advice. Using this article without permission is a violation of copyright laws.

January 26, 2010June 27, 2019

Transfer tax controversy brews in Maryland Counties

by Dan Krell © 2010
DanKrell.com

Most real estate issues usually do not grab people’s attention – unless they are the ones affected. Eminent domain is a prime example; those affected usually become embroiled in the controversy. One current issue that you may have heard (although you may not have become fully aware) of is the transfer tax controversy that’s brewing in Montgomery and Anne Arundel Counties. The anticipated opinion on the controversy from the Maryland Attorney General may have lasting and widespread consequences on how transfer tax is calculated in this state.

The controversy surrounds the decision from Montgomery and Anne Arundel Counties to collect transfer tax on the “forgiven” mortgage amounts in a short sale. At face value, the policy of collecting transfer tax on the unpaid portion of a short sale appears to be a way for the counties to compensate for their declining tax base; however the fundamental method of calculating state and county transfer tax may be more the issue. On January 12th, however, Montgomery County put “a hold” on the collection of transfer tax of the “forgiven” mortgage amount until the Maryland Attorney General issues his opinion.

The “forgiven” mortgage amount is the amount that the seller’s lender agrees to not collect at the settlement of a short sale. However, this amount is not literally forgiven as the lender typically either considers it income and issues a 1099 to the seller or pursues payment through a deficiency judgment against the seller. Since part of the requirement for a short sale is usually to provide evidence of a hardship, some critics have argued that the collection of transfer tax on “forgiven” mortgage amounts to be punitive.

The collection of transfer tax on forgiven mortgage amounts should not be confused with “nominal consideration” rules that are used in some jurisdictions around the country (including Washington, DC). “Nominal consideration” rules typically calculate additional transfer tax when the sales price is less than the assessed value. In Washington, DC, a transaction is considered to be of “nominal consideration” when the sales price is less than 30% of the assessed value.

Title 13 of the Tax-Property section of the Code of Maryland (COMAR) discusses the collection of transfer tax by the State and counties, as well as tax rates and possible exemptions. COMAR discusses various ways in which transfer taxes are calculated and collected; for example tax is calculated on the “consideration payable for the instrument of writing”; and the tax is “imposed on the instrument of writing.”

Some may have mistakenly thought that consideration is only the sales price and the instrument in writing is only the deed; however, others have argued that consideration also includes additional amounts involved in a transaction (such as assumed loans) and instruments in writing to also include deeds of trust. I am not an attorney and I am not attempting to practice or interpret law, but it appears that clarification from the Attorney General has become necessary in interpreting “consideration” and “instruments of writing” when calculating transfer tax in today’s market.

You might consider the collection of forgiven mortgage amounts another sign of a depreciated real estate market. However, the future of transfer tax calculation and collection (at least locally) is sure to be affected by the highly anticipated opinion of Attorney General Gansler.

This article is not intended to provide nor should it be relied upon for legal and financial advice. Using this this article without permission is a violation of copyright laws. Copyright © 2010 Dan Krell

**Update—HB 590/SB 657 – Taxation of Forgiven Debt in Short Sales
STATUS: PASSED – Effective May 20, 2010.
This law clarifies that recordation and transfer taxes MAY NOT be imposed on the forgiven debt in short sale transactions.